Skip to main content

Publications

3453 results

Put Your Mouth Where Your Money Is: A Field Experiment Encouraging Donors to Share About Charit

Marketing Science
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): I. M. Silver and D. A. Small
Abstract

Sharing about charity online or in personal conversations can help raise awareness and bolster fundraising efforts for good causes. However, when deciding whether to tell others about their charitable giving, donors may focus more on possible risks to their reputation (e.g., of seeming braggy, inauthentic) than on potential word-of-mouth benefits for the charity. In a large, preregistered field experiment, we tested a post-donation intervention designed to encourage word-of-mouth by reorienting donors to the idea that sharing about charity means doing more good; 77,485 donors received either a control or treatment message asking them to share a link to the cause via social media, text, or email. Compared with the organization’s standard solicitation (“Please share your donation…”), our intervention emphasized consequences of sharing for the cause (“Your donation can start a chain reaction…”). This brief message increased click-through by 5.1% and likelihood of recruiting at least one later donation via word-of-mouth by 12.4%. Exploratory follow-up analyses suggest that these effects are most pronounced among larger-gift donors; the more donors gave, the more responsive they were to the intervention. Whereas many field experiments aim to increase giving directly, we test an intervention designed to boost word-of-mouth for worthy causes. We discuss approaches for encouraging sharing in the domain of charity and beyond.

Racial/Ethnic Heterogeneity in the Relationship Between an Early Elementary School ADHD Diagnosis and Later Child Wellbeing

RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): J. Owens and X. Cao
Abstract

Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is America’s most common childhood disorder. Although an ADHD diagnosis can bring positives, recent research uncovers potential negatives associated with diagnosis. This study examines understudied racial-ethnic heterogeneity in the relationships between an early elementary school ADHD diagnosis—with or without medication treatment—and children’s future perceived self-competence, teacher-rated school behaviors, and parent-rated educational expectations. Findings are consistent with the notion that diagnosis can trigger racialized patterns of stigma. That is, relative to undiagnosed matches of the same social class and regardless of medication use, diagnosed Black children demonstrate worse teacher-rated school behaviors, diagnosed White children report poorer perceived self-competence, and parents of diagnosed Hispanic children report poorer educational expectations. Racialized patterns of stigma might amplify the consequences of negative-ability stereotyping on Black children, academic pressure on White children, and mental health stigma on Hispanic children. Findings also highlight the challenges of identification posed by differential unobserved selection into diagnosis.

Recent Developments in Financial Risk and the Real Economy

Annual Review of Financial Economics
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): I. Dew-Becker and S. Giglio
Abstract

In this article, we review recent developments in macroeconomics and finance on the relationship between financial risk and the real economy. We focus on three specific topics: (a) the term structure of uncertainty, (b) time variation—specifically, the long-term decline—in the variance risk premium, and (c) time variation in conditional skewness. We also introduce two new data series: implied volatility from one-day options on grains for the period 1906–1936 and prices of cliquet options, which provide insurance against single-day crashes on the S&P 500. Both series give some context to the recent rise in trade in extremely short-dated options. Finally, we discuss new avenues for future research.

Refugees are Hosted in Highly Vulnerable Communitie

AEA Papers & Proceedings
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): C. A. Davis, P. López-Peña, A. M. Mobarak, and J. Y. Wen
Abstract

Low- and middle-income nations host 76 percent of the world's refugees. This study uses original data to explore within-country spatial variability in refugee-hosting responsibilities. We find that hosting responsibilities for the displaced Rohingya people in Bangladesh are allocated in similarly unequal fashion when analyzed at the national, regional, and microregional levels. Refugee camps are placed in socioeconomically disadvantaged communities relative to both Bangladesh as a whole and surrounding areas. Our findings underscore the importance of considering host communities in the coordination of humanitarian responses to refugee crises to prevent economic hardship and political backlash.

Retail Investors and ESG News

Journal of Accounting and Economics
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): Q. Li, E. M. Watts, and C. Zhu
Abstract

An important debate exists around the extent to which retail investors make sustainable investments and, if they do, why. We contribute to this debate by investigating the aggregate trading patterns of retail investors around a comprehensive sample of key environmental, social, and governance (ESG) news events for U.S. firms. We show that ESG news events appear to be an important factor in retail investors’ portfolio allocation decisions. Yet, inconsistent with arguments about retail investors’ nonpecuniary preferences, our evidence shows that retail investors mainly trade on this information when they deem it financially material to a company’s stock performance. We also find their net trading demand predicts abnormal returns in the subsample of financially material events, consistent with retail traders benefiting from incorporating ESG-related information into their decision-making when it influences firm value. Overall we conclude that the average U.S. retail investor cares about firms’ ESG activities but primarily to the extent these activities matter for company financial performance.

Risk Aversion and Double Marginalization

Journal of Industrial Economics
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): S. Ghili and M. Schmitt
Abstract

In vertical markets, eliminating double marginalization with a two-part tariff may not be possible due to risk aversion. When demand is uncertain, contracts with large fixed fees expose the downstream firm to more risk than contracts that are more reliant on variable fees. In equilibrium, contracts may thus rely on variable fees, giving rise to double marginalization. Coun- terintuitively, however, we show that increased demand risk or risk aversion can actually mitigate double marginalization. We also characterize several sufficient conditions under which increased risk or risk aversion is guar- anteed to exacerbate double marginalization. We conclude by discussing potential applications and extensions.

Robust Dynamic Staffing with Predictions

Working Papers
Published: 2024
Author(s): Y. Feng, V. H. Manshadi, R. Niazedeh, and S. Neyshabouri
Abstract

We consider a natural dynamic staffing problem in which a decision-maker sequentially hires workers over a finite horizon to meet an unknown demand revealed at the end. Predictions about demand arrive over time and become increasingly accurate, while worker availability decreases. This creates a fundamental trade-off between hiring early to avoid understaffing (when workers are more available but forecasts are less reliable) and hiring late to avoid overstaffing (when forecasts are more accurate but availability is lower). This problem is motivated by last-mile delivery operations, where companies such as Amazon rely on gig-economy workers whose availability declines closer to the operating day.

To address practical limitations of Bayesian models (in particular, to remain agnostic to the underlying forecasting method), we study this problem under adversarial predictions. In this model, sequential predictions are adversarially chosen uncertainty intervals that (approximately) contain the true demand. The objective is to minimize worst-case staffing imbalance cost. Our main result is a simple and computationally efficient online algorithm that is minimax optimal. We first characterize the minimax cost against a restricted adversary via a polynomial-size linear program, then show how to emulate this solution in the general case. While our base model focuses on a single demand, we extend the framework to multiple demands (with egalitarian or utilitarian objectives), to settings with costly reversals of hiring decisions, and to inconsistent prediction intervals. We also introduce a practical "re-solving" variant of our algorithm, which we prove is also minimax optimal. Finally, motivated by our collaboration with Amazon Last-Mile, we conduct numerical experiments showing that our algorithms outperform Bayesian heuristics in both cost and speed, and are competitive with (approximate or exact) Bayesian-optimal policies when those can be computed.

Searching for Rewards

Management Science, revise and resubmit for the 2nd round review
Working Papers
Published: 2024
Author(s): T. ke, J. Shin, and X. Zhu
Abstract

Loyalty programs are pervasive across numerous markets, offering members rewards based on their past purchases for future benefits. This study explores the dynamics of loyalty pro- grams within a repeated ordered search framework, where consumers sequentially search for the optimal product across multiple firms over two periods. Our findings reveal that firms strategically use price discounts and rewards to influence consumer behaviors. Price discounts discourage further search in the current shopping period, while rewards encourage consumer loyalty by inducing prominence in subsequent visits. As search costs increase, firms tend to offer lower price discounts but higher rewards. This strategy increases industry profit but reduces consumer surplus. Compared with its absence, loyalty programs decrease both indus- try profit and consumer welfare, leading to a lose-lose outcome. Moreover, we demonstrate that when the market is heterogeneous, high-type firms, with larger networks, offer lower re- wards but achieve higher second-period prices and greater consumer loyalty, contrasting with low-type firms that compensate with higher rewards for their smaller networks. This study offers new insights into the strategic use of loyalty programs and their impact on market competition.

Segmentation and Beliefs: A Theory of Self-Fulfilling Idiosyncratic Risk

Working Papers
Published: 2024
Author(s): P. Khorrami and A. K. Zentefis
Abstract

We study a multi-location model with financial market segmentation that permits
self-fulfilling fluctuations. Such fluctuations are necessarily idiosyncratic, but their
volatility varies systematically with an aggregate latent factor. We thus provide a
coordination-based microfoundation for time-varying idiosyncratic risk. A key as-
sumption of our analysis is that cash flow growth rates (e.g., firm profit growth,
asset dividend growth, or country output growth) rise with valuations. We con-
sider three applications: (i) firm dynamics and their risk factor structure; (ii) law
of one price violations in finance; and (iii) exchange rate disconnect in international
macroeconomics.

SELCO Foundation

Case Study
Published: 2024
Author(s): Tony Sheldon
Suggested Citation: Jaan Elias, Morgan Yucel, Greg MacDonald, Tony Sheldon, "SELCO Foundation: Diffusing a User-centered Ecosystem Approach to Sustainable Livelihood Promotion," Yale Case 24-012, July 23, 2024.
Abstract

The SELCO Foundation, established by Harish Hande in 2010, focuses on providing decentralized renewable energy (DRE) solutions to rural, impoverished communities, emphasizing a user-centered, ecosystem-based approach. The Foundation aims to integrate sustainable energy solutions within the daily lives and activities of users through comprehensive support structures, involving technical, financial, and community partnerships.

SELCO's methodology is characterized by a design-thinking approach that considers the entire ecosystem surrounding the end-user. This involves understanding user needs, developing customized devices, securing appropriate financing, and ensuring maintenance and support through local networks. The Foundation works closely with rural households, small technical enterprises, financial institutions, and community organizations to pilot and scale interventions, creating what Hande terms "Lego Blocks" of innovation that can be adapted by other development organizations globally.

Despite its innovative model, the SELCO Foundation faces several challenges in diffusing its approach to other organizations. One significant challenge is the fragmented and often outdated support ecosystems in under-developed regions, such as India’s Northeast. Often, SELCO must incubate new support organizations rather than merely aligning existing ones, complicating project scopes, especially in regions lacking the necessary ecosystem components entirely.

Cultural and geographical specificity presents another difficulty, requiring tailored interventions unique to each region. What works in one area may not be directly replicable elsewhere, complicating diffusion efforts. Financially, other organizations may find that securing patient, long-term funding to support iterative, ecosystem-building approach is difficult, as traditional funders often prioritize immediate results.

Shaping Opinions in Social Networks with Shadow Banning

PLOS One
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): Y-S. Chen and T. Zaman
Abstract

he proliferation of harmful content and misinformation on social networks necessitates content moderation policies to maintain platform health. One such policy is shadow banning, which limits content visibility. The danger of shadow banning is that it can be misused by social media platforms to manipulate opinions. Here we present an optimization based approach to shadow banning that can shape opinions into a desired distribution and scale to large networks. Simulations on real network topologies show that our shadow banning policies can shift opinions and increase or decrease opinion polarization. We find that if one shadow bans with the aim of shifting opinions in a certain direction, the resulting shadow banning policy can appear neutral. This shows the potential for social media platforms to misuse shadow banning without being detected. Our results demonstrate the power and danger of shadow banning for opinion manipulation in social networks.

Sparse and Faithful Explanations Without Sparse Models

International conference on artificial intelligence and statistics
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): Y. Sun, Z. Chen, V. Orlandi, T. Wang, and C. Rudin
Abstract

Even if a model is not globally sparse, it is possible for decisions made from that model to be accurately and faithfully described by a small number of features. For instance, an application for a large loan might be denied to someone because they have no credit history, which overwhelms any evidence towards their creditworthiness. In this work, we introduce the Sparse Explanation Value (SEV), a new way of measuring sparsity in machine learning models. In the loan denial example above, the SEV is 1 because only one factor is needed to explain why the loan was denied. SEV is a measure of decision sparsity rather than overall model sparsity, and we are able to show that many machine learning models -- even if they are not sparse -- actually have low decision sparsity, as measured by SEV. SEV is defined using movements over a hypercube, allowing SEV to be defined consistently over various model classes, with movement restrictions reflecting real-world constraints. We proposed the algorithms that reduce SEV without sacrificing accuracy, providing sparse and completely faithful explanations, even without globally sparse models.

Spatial Distribution of Access to Service: Theory and Evidence from Ridesharing

Working Papers
Published: 2024
Author(s): S. Ghili, V. Kumar, and F. Teng
Abstract

This paper studies access to services across geographical regions, using both theoretical and empirical analyses. We model and examine the effects of economies of density in ridesharing markets. Our model predicts that (i) economies of density skew access to rideshareing service away from less dense regions, (ii) the skew will be more pronounced for smaller platforms (i.e., "thinner markets"), and (iii) rideshare platforms do not find this skew efficient and thus use prices and wages to mitigate (but not eliminate) it. We show that these insights are robust to whether the source of economies of density is the supply-side or the demand-side. We then calibrate our model using ride-level Uber data from New York City. We devise an identification strategy based on relative flows of rides among regions which allows us to infer unobsrevable potential demand in different boroughs. We use the model to simulate counterfactual scenarios providing insights on platform optimal pricing with and without spatial price discrimination, the role of market thickness, the impact of prices/wages on access to rides, and the effects of minimum-wage regulations on access equity across regions.

Steering Labor Mobility Through Innovation

Working Papers
Published: 2024
Author(s): S. Ma, W. Wang, and Y. Wu
Abstract

This paper argues that firms proactively use innovation decisions to influence the mobility and human capital accumulation of their workers. We develop a dynamic model in which workers conduct R&D projects, accumulating both general and firm-specific human capital. Firms choose the scope of innovation, influencing the type of human capital workers accumulate during the process. Pursuing more general innovation leads to increased knowledge redeployability for the firm at the cost of more difficult employee retention. We estimate the model using granular innovation production and mobility data of three million inventors. Our model closely matches the observed mobility and innovation specificity over inventors' life cycles. Empirical estimates of the model parameters imply that 24% of observed innovation specificity among U.S. firms is driven by their labor market considerations, which enhances the firm value but lowers the inventors' surplus.

Stock Market Wealth and Entrepreneurship

National Bureau of Economic Research
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): G. Chodorow-Reich, P. T Nenov, V. Santos, and A. Simsek
Abstract

We use data on stock portfolios of Norwegian households to show that stock market wealth increases entrepreneurship by relaxing financial constraints. Our research design isolates idiosyncratic variation in household-level stock market returns. An increase in stock market wealth increases the propensity to start a firm, with the response concentrated in households with moderate levels of financial wealth, for whom a 20 percent increase in wealth due to a positive stock return increases the likelihood to start a firm by about 20%, and in years when the aggregate stock market return in Norway is high. We develop a method to study the effect of wealth on firm outcomes that corrects for the bias introduced by selection into entrepreneurship. Higher wealth causally increases firm profitability, an indication that it relaxes would-be entrepreneurs’ financial constraints. Consistent with this interpretation, the pass-through from stock wealth into equity in the new firm is one-for-one.

Survey of Resolution and Restructuring in Europe: Pre- and Post-BRRD

Journal of Financial Crises, Yale Program on Financial Stability
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): G. Feldberg, C. M. McNamara, C. K. Mott, S. Gupta, and A. Metrick
Abstract

This paper surveys 19 case studies of bank resolutions and restructurings across 15 Key Design Decisions. It focuses on interventions that occurred in Europe both in the years leading up to the adoption of the Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive (BRRD) in 2014 (when many jurisdictions were constrained by a lack of legal authority) and in the years after the BRRD was in place. The main themes that emerge are: (a) the need for resolution and restructuring to eliminate uncertainty about an institution’s solvency by closing it, recapitalizing it, or merging it with a healthier institution; (b) the importance of effective valuation in achieving this result; (c) the necessity of clarity in the treatment of creditors; and (d) the value of a credible bail-in tool to incentivize creditors to agree to solutions outside of resolution.

Symmetry and the Sixth Force: The Essential Role of Complements

CPI Antitrust Chronicle
Articles
Published: 2024
Author(s): A. Brandenburger and B. Nalebuff
Abstract

More than forty years later, the five-forces model (Porter, 1980) remains one of the most influential frameworks for formulating strategy. Yet there is a hole in the model, namely, the force of complements. Porter (2008) has advocated against including complements as a force. He argues that the effect of complements fails a test of monotonicity and must be understood via the existing five forces. However, this monotonicity test conflates the positive direct impact of comple- ments with the ambiguous effect complements have on the other forces. Also, the structure of the complements industry can have a direct effect on industry profits, with no impact on the five forces. Because complements have traditionally been neglected, strategy towards them is under-developed relative to strategy built on the other five forces. We provide strategic insights that come from giving equal billing to complements. Starting from Porter's checklist for substitutes and its associated strategies, we create an analogous checklist for complements. Since complements are a symmetric counterpart to substitutes, up to a sign change, the associated strategies are symmetric in the same fashion. Including complements as a sixth force makes the five-forces framework more logically complete and more valuable.